However, I still believe that a person decides their own limitations by choosing to either give up or continue forward with whatever they pursue. Thats rightthe internet isnt real! Email. Nah. The first phase of growth has been accomplished. Waitare you just saying random things and patting yourself on the back for it? Oklet me clarifyI dont see a lot of GOOD hand work in TKD. Writing the checks I do, just for another belt for my kids and I, seems alittle high. Lets see, what elsejudo. If you cant say it with eloquence, then do the world a favor and dont say it at all. Taekwondo teaches you elegance, and if thats what you wanna learn, to each his own. And we do more then just kicks. The West for the most part has lost the original intent of the martial arts almost universally regardless of style. You should do a for profit (McDojos) vs, smaller not for profit schools. If martial arts (any martial arts) can help her improve her life and confidence, Im all for it and would never call it useless. I really dont see this as something people need to blow a gasket over. Instead, we are encouraged to use use our hands and block. I love kickboxing, kobujutsu, karate and krav maga also enjoyed taijutsu, not practicing currently. Non-instructor students may wear a uniform with "TAEKWONDO" and an ATA patch on the back, however, these students do not wear their names on their backs. I can say being a practitioner of tkd that alot of this guy is saying have some valid points. We live in the real world not a movie. NoI did not meet a wrong instructor. They make the snapping sound when you punch. My personal experience in TKD is from 3 dojangs I have attended and four from my sisters who are both high ranking black belts. Fast forward to 2020 we put my son in a local TKD center and it was so much different than the TKD I took. If you dont notice it, it probably just means youre the source or havent been around long enough. Of course I understand that your life no longer has room for martial arts, Ive had to make tough calls as well in life that have lead me away from martial arts on more than one occasion. Im ok with it going either way. My instructor primary teaches taekwondo but most of our tests are self defense training ie takedowns, submissions, joint locks etc. At least my son will have learned how to avoid a fight or at worst diffuse it because the odds on him coming up against a black belt in Krav Maga in high school is like me winning the lottery twice in one day. how smart he/she using it. 5 Reasons Taekwondo is Useless? TKD is a flawed system, but it is not a bad way to get started in martial arts if you find a good group to train with. Why is forbidding hand techniques to the head wrong? WTF south ITF north? They kicked the shit out of me. Next time, have some credibilty before you bag on one of the greatest martial arts ever. Remember, any form of taekwondo is ineffective if you dont follow the principles. If someone walks up to you, out of the blue, and asks: What did you say say to me?, the correct answer is a knee to the balls, an elbow smash to the nose, and a punch to the throat. Such idiotic machismo BS does not deserve to continue and thankfully modern TKD has at least developed some common sense by encouraging head gear. When I trained for competition in the 80s, there were no pads, no headgear and knockouts were encouraged. Youre funnya little sad, but funny. Underneath the patch is the instructor's name, either as "JOHN DOE" or "J. Lets begin with general differences: While all the three bodies are extremely credible, these have different purposes. I have been doing it since I was 8. TKD is a revolving door but a profitable revolving door nonetheless. The difference from one to the other was vast. Ive never seen that happen in a fight. Lee; Grand Master William Clark; Grand Master Robert Allemier, White Belt (Songahm 1) - "Pure and without the knowledge of Songahm Taekwondo. Now, the combat version has more emphasis on weapon disarming, pull-and-hit, and most of all killing the opponent in a single strike or two. Now, tournaments arent bad, they are a great place to practice harder and faster techniques against another opponent, but they build bad habits if you focus on them too much. so i did sign him up but opted for Jiu Jitsu since i thought that at least was somewhat practical if he happens to get in a fight at some point. The style doesnt make the man, the man makes the style. This article makes me laugh =) Id like to see you come down to our school and try going a few rounds with us. Thank you, have a good day! It was a unique situation where some dork needed a humbling and got what he had long coming to him. Lee since July 2022. In the day-to-day world, what will determine your enjoyment, progress and satisfaction is the master and the school that results from him/her. Well, WTF Olympic TKD as a whole is pretty much watered down karate and practically worthless as a serious martial art. In the end though, i believe it truly depends on the dojang you attend. Although if your total training from white to Dan including tests cost only $250 then wellthat is as pretty sweet deal. But by itself its near useless in combat situations. As a (former) practitioner and competitor in both ITF and WTF Taekwondo, I want to slap the shit out of everybody in that video. Simple. Are you saying because I walked away from the horrid blot on MA that is TKD that I am bitter? (balls, throat, eyes) I've been studying at an ATA affiliated school now for over 3 years and it's been overall a pleasant experience for me. Good news, nobody asked you to agree with my opinion. Thats right, Taekwon-do. 1) Biggest Moronic Are you sure? Consider the average MA student, pick a style, who trains, gets in shape, and is moderately serious working at training a couple hours a day for a couple years: are they better able to defend themselves as compared to the person they were two years ago? Differences in the uniforms are visible in all the three styles, noticeable ones include, the length of shirt, traditional robe style in ATA, new design approach in WT, shorter sleeves in ITF and major visual pattern difference. People seem to think I quit because I had a bad dojo or teacher and that is flat out false. There are many kids with ADHD, overweight , low self esteem, adults living a sedentary life , out there who could benefit from Taekwondo, Karate or any other martial arts. The Won Yo form is in Shotokan, Okinawan Karate, TKD and Tangsoodo. If you lack certain basics like balance, coordination, reflexes, discipline, intelligence, etc then NO SYSTEM is gonna work for you. I know your club tells you martial arts are for life. You were bang on the money with your first sentence. Ever heard of boxing skill? Tkd is a nice sport, if you love forms and trickong it is a great martial ART. Going to either a local or national TaeKwonDo Sparring Tournament is much more exciting for me now. One rule breach will be a warning, two will be a 7 day ban, three will be permanent ban. But defense was my main forte when I was little and wanted join karate (and getting that Black belt, which took me 7 years to get. You act like Ive dishonored your family or something. a) Is it possible for this to still be a "McDojo" where even if I got a black belt it still isn't worth anything? No experience with it so I dont really have any opinion on it one way or the other. 1. Please be aware of the rules below. ATA Martial Arts is the worlds largest martial arts organization with certified instructors teaching Songahm Taekwondo. Thats actually rather impressive. I dont have to meet you to know that you are a moron. Your All-Inclusive Guide to The Roundhouse Kick, 11 Tips For Returning to Taekwondo After a Long Break, Taekwondo Belts And Ranks - All Organizations (World, Your Complete Guide To The Hook Kick or Whip Kick. Many katas are practically identical to Shotokan. They overcharge for everything and there gear completely sucks. Ya ive always really liked the uniforms. My ten year old son in in it! I'm getting reviews all over the internet (both on yelp and on internet forums) that ATA is a joke and a money grabbing scheme/mcdojo where they overcharge you and will hand out a blackbelt to just anyone in an extremely short amount of time with little effort. Who the hell was that guy?? GTF, ITF, AIMAA and many more styles would prove you wrong on the punching point. Right? Me makers heart sadly go bad no like fun makers. TKD forms has 7 to 1 punching and hands to kicks. They take it very serious, while making it just fun enough to keep the kids motivated and interested. this stuff will get you killed if you had to use it in the real world. I studied bixing, shotokan and wadoryu karate as a youth and now itf taekwondo . Dont piss off a junior belt that has spent any time in another fighting art unless you want to discover just how low TKD is on the martial arts food chain. The other three black belts that where given where to adults. Now go have a gooder day. ATA vs WTF Curious to your guys opinions on ATA taekwondo vs WTF taekwondo and ata tkd in general. My opinion of the ATA is that their curriculum is certainly a serviceable curriculum and is neither superior nor inferior to Chang hon TKD (ITF) and Kukkiwon TKD (the WTF is actually the NGB of the sport of taekwondo; the style itself is Kukkiwon taekwondo). WTF is watered down and it makes absolutely no difference which school or instructor you have. Thank you DP you made my day (but not just you also Jesus because it is Easter. Its all about whether its business or a passion. He has made lots of friends and truly enjoys going to practice and practicing at home. I was wondering when you were gonna pop up in this thread. Main thing is you must have passion also to learn. My son is in TKD, two of my sisters are black belts, and I can say unequivocally that WTF TKD is NOT the place to go for fist work. I left tkd as a green belt ( 6th rank) and have since practiced more of an American kickboxing style, along with tang soo do and although some arts are more effective, the mind of the student is absolutely the biggest factor of weather you can fight your way out of a paper bag. What should we learn or teach if TKD is imperfect ? You lose credibility the moment you dont make a distinction between the Sport of TKD and the Martial Art of TKD. After 2015, with the promotion of a second concurrent 9th Degree (Richard Reed), the title "Presiding Grand Master" is now used to indicate the Grand Master chosen from among the group of 9th degrees to be in charge of the martial arts side of ATA. 2 yr. ago 3rd Dan I've posted my personal experience with ATA before and saved it for when the topic comes up again. I am lucky enough to have a Tae Kwon Do Ji Do Kwan school in my area and I would love to see my school go up against an ata school. White, Orange, Yellow, Camo, Green, Purple, Blue, Brown, Red and Black stripes run along the center of the belt from one end to the other. One poor or bad experience In a Martial Arts school, does not define the style, just that school, and the teacher. During the next 60 years, major changes occurred in the army version of this art. Punching is allowed to the chest protector only. When H.U. not being allowed to punch to the face whilst sparring, ha ha what a joke! It was 1998. But if I can respond cool and collected and all I get back from you are the ramblings of a madman, maybe we should part ways before things get ugly. Taekwon-Do was built on a foundation of Shotokan but it has surpassed it by leaps and bounds. Not sure how it is today, but at the time, it was more of a point sparring style then. Different places, different prices. The best kicks and kicking training in the world is available only through studying Taekwondo from a Korean WTF accredited master. I find flaws in your side of this debate/argument/self-righteous opinion or whatever u want to call it. A great competition combo (if you have a strong punch) is to heavily punch the chest that he will feel it through the armor then as you gain the right distance you can now deliver some 45degree kicks and bullet combos to your imbalanced opponent. Theres a huge difference between martial art fight and real-life situation fight. Cuz UFC is the REAL DEAL, bro. Its true the competition TKD is not functional against punches or grappling because they are forbidden in it, so the form is awful from martial arts viewpoint, but it is a sport. Basically taekwondo came from a korean game taekyon wherein they tie their hands and spar with their feet like what the sport part of TKD does. The kid section, yea thats stupid, I did TKD as a kid too, we recognized it as a joke pretty fast. Pick the right instructor not the colour full school. If you take nothing else from this article, pleaseplease just remove these hideous iron-ons from your already hideous uniform. Feel free to substitute TKD wherever karate is mentioned. The commercialization of Tae Kwon Do that begin in the 70s has turned this particular style into a chain of schools with revolving doors. #2 Goes back to the first general point made, Sport does not allow punching to the face, to transition that and suggest that it means people who train WTF TKD dont know HOW to punch or block again shows a lack of credibility as you lump sport and art together.Thats like saying someone in MMA doesnt know how to kick someone in the nuts simply because its not a viable strike within the rules of the sport match. And I am just 13. It may make the child feel good and confident about having a black belt and it may make the parents happy, but martial arts are not about belts and uniforms and trophies! Thank you Jesus for giving us DP and coming back to life, amen.), Your email address will not be published. Some of it is just ridiculous: camouflage belts, copyrighted forms, equipment contracts (anything and all gear has to be purchased from the organization), not recognized by the Kukkiwon (the Korean governmental agency that oversees Taekwondo), important self defense training is only taught to instructors, you are . And yes that gear, while protecting superficially, can arguably be more harmful than helpful by adding more bulk and surface to hit while not protecting the wearer against internal injury such as concussions and bruising. Lee and Cesar Ozuna. when reading through your article , i was waiting to reach the part which said my style was better than yours. Reddit, Inc. 2023. I mean its in the fricking Olympics! Our TKD dojang (ITA) mixes in some Combat Hapkido, BJJ and Kenpo. Thats Steve Grandeza of Philippine Moo Duk Kwan Tang Soo Do Soo Bahk Do. You dont even rank on the top 100 of my list for today alone. Which martial arts do you use for your own personal style ? You want to defend yourself then at least learn the basics or join a Krav class or something. I would much rather fight some clown on the street than any student in my dojang. Compare the sloppiness of a Poomse to the focus of a kata. Youre honestly so stupid it boggles my mind. Just liking to make watch son go TKD. I have something, fairly scientific on an impartial reputable SCIENCE AND HISTORY channel, NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC, thats been around for 30 years. I could beat Roger Federer in a Badminton match but does he care? As an example, if a WTF practitioner is throwing a punch, only shoulder strength is being utilized in the form. This wasnt meant to be an attack at all, however as an experienced TKD student, its obvious you were just a casual passerby. Does that count? If one wants to believe that the modern day street fighter, whatever that is, is somehow the most effective: well, you cannot combat stupidity! So while yes, there are many rather silly things about TKD I understand there are some things about it which are indeed good. My old Shotokan dojo wouldnt even consider child admission until 12. The differences can be observed through history, applied techniques, tendencies, approach, rules, patterns & forms. ", Purple Belt (Inwha 1) - "Coming to the mountain. For someone that has 15 years under his belt as a karate student, it doesnt sound like youve learned anything, especially the part about honor and respect.
Oxford Health Plans, Inc,
Articles I